The Company You Keep: a Robert Redford film.
The movie opens with TV news pictures from the late ‘60s and a short history
lesson about the Weather Underground. An appropriate beginning as
many viewers are not going to understand the movie if they have no remembrance
of how part of the anti-Vietnam war protest went
violent. This movie, which takes place in the present, is about
individuals who were active participants in a Weather Underground incident and
who then went underground. Robert Redford plays the lead character, Nick
Sloan. He also directed the film. After going underground,
Sloan resurfaces as a public interest lawyer in Albany, NY. His
fabricated persona becomes suspect after the character played by Susan Sarandon
is arrested. This occurs at the
beginning of the film. The Sarandon character, who has decided to
surrender, is instead arrested by the FBI. The lead FBI agent is played
by Terrence Howard. The movie is not FBI friendly and Howard’s
performance is not helpful. Sloan
is flushed out by a young newspaper reporter,
Ben Shepard, played by Shia LeBeouf.
The film moves between how the reporter discovers what three decades of FBI
work had not, and Redford on the run. Turns out that some of the old
radicals had maintained communication channels
over the past 30 years. It is these minor roles that make this film
an enjoyable viewing experience. Nick Nolte is not on screen very
long but he dominates for his duration. Julie Christie was Redford’s
girlfriend in the day and he is traveling the country to find her because she
is the one who knows the true story regarding the incident that forced Redford
to recreate himself. Christie is now a drug runner living in
Northern California with Mac, played by Sam Elliot. Christie does not
look her 71 years and she remains excellent. We also have actors Richard
Jenkins and Stephen Root playing other members of the University of Michigan
group. Stanley Tucci plays the newspaper editor and Ben Shepard’s
boss. The film cast is excellent. As to the storyline, I had
mixed emotions after the recent events in Boston. I bet if you asked
most Americans to name the most successful organization in planting bombs in
American history, they would not guess Weather Underground; in this instance,
my reference to “success” relates to number of incidents and not death
count. Since I’m old enough to have been in college when much of what
led to the formation of the Weather Underground occurred, I remember the
incidents that are the understory for this movie. I also recall that the
acts of the Underground were not the modern indiscriminate bombings by
religious zealots. Still, a bomb is a bomb is a
bomb. The fact that the movie made me think is another plus to go
with the excellent acting. The movie kept my attention for the 125
minutes. Unfortunately, Redford could not resist a Hollywood ending
to his film. I would have preferred the film ending about 5 minutes
earlier than it does. I will place at the end of my blog what should
have been the closing scene. One additional comment: the script is
weak and most of the characters, despite the excellent acting, are too one dimensional.
Nolte and Sarandon were notable exceptions and more screen time for them would
have been a plus. Redford’s time as a lead actor has passed.
POSTSCRIPT ON MOVIE ENDING: Redford and Christie meet at a cabin in Upper Minnesota. The FBI had tracked Redford character but has no idea Christie is present. They run from the cabin in opposite directions and Christie makes it to a lake wharf where a small boat is present. Then there is a long shot of the boat in the lake. I would have ented the movie with that scene.
Monday, April 29, 2013
Thursday, April 18, 2013
Movie: 42
42: telling the story of Jackie Robinson integrating
major league baseball. The movie covers the period from 1945
through Robinson’s rookie season with the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947.
This is not a biography of Jackie Robinson. Instead,
using baseball and the Robinson story, a
snapshot of America right after winning WWII is
being told. While every baseball fan should see this movie, “42” is
more than just a baseball film. The movie opens with a background voice talking about the soldiers
returning home but despite the victory over fascism, segregation through Jim
Crow laws remain rampant throughout much of
the country. The racism that existed was blatant and the movie does
not hide this fact. Nor does it hide the anti-Semitism which was
also prevalent. A scene shows the manager of the Philadelphia
Phillies asking reporters why can’t I call
Robinson a Nigger if I can call Hank Greenberg a Kike. The
adventures of Leo Durocher (Christopher Meloni) provide an interesting
counterpoint. For you non-baseball fans, Durocher was the manager of
the Dodgers who got suspended in 1947 for his lack of morals - he was dating a Hollywood starlet who got
divorced over the relationship. I
could launch into a discussion of sexual morality verses treating each human as
an equal, but I won’t. Chadwick
Boseman is a credible Jackie Robinson and Nicole Beharie plays his wife
Rachel. The movie is also a love story as
they appear to have had a remarkable relationship. Mrs. Robinson is
still alive and actively working with the education foundation bearing Jackie’s
name. The integration of baseball happened as early as 1947 due to
one man, Branch Rickey. He was a lone voice.
Rickey was the general manager of the Dodgers and it was through his
drive and the character of Robinson that baseball integration occurred when it
did, with success. Harrison Ford does a marvelous job portraying
Rickey. The movie was written and directed by Brian Helgeland and he
is not into complexity. The movie score is unfortunate. It has the sound of a ‘40s movie, which is not
meant as a compliment. Using a movie score to tell the viewer what
is important is not a device I endorse. The
128 minute movie is complimentary to some
baseball players (Pee Wee Reese and Ralph Branca) and shows the blatant racism
of others (Dixie Walker and Enos Slaughter). An individual who is
shown to have evolved thorough his interaction with Robinson was Bobby Bragan. There is also a
father/son scene which shows how racist acts are passed
from father to son. I recommend that you watch history being told in an entertaining movie but
afterwards think about what has transpired during the past 66 years.
Saturday, April 6, 2013
Movie: The Gatekeepers
The Gatekeepers: an Israeli Oscar nominated
documentary. This is a remarkable 97 minute film that if you have
any interest in Israel, the Middle East or just foreign policy decision making,
you should see. The film maker, Dror Moreh, somehow obtained
interviews with the past six heads from 1980 of Shin Bet, the Israeli security
service. I understand some of them had never sat for interviews
before. The interviews are interspersed with historical documentary
footage. This is not a talking heads film. Instead, the
points being made by the Shin Bet leaders regarding the occupation of the
Palestinian territories are illustrated with contemporary film stock and very
inventive computer-generated imagery. I am curious whether you are able
to spot what is computer generated as opposed to actual historical
footage. Note that this movie also confronts internal Jewish
terrorism. Shin Bet is more than a secret service organization and
closer to our FBI. Each of these guys are brutally honest about the
political situation they operate within and the lack of moral courage as to
many of the Israeli politicians. There is one major exception:
Yitzhak Rabin. The movie shows how an assassination can change the
course of history. While I’m not a believer in the great men theory
of history, there is no question certain individuals can change the
course. Rabin almost became one of those individuals but his vanity
in not wearing a bullet proof vest as recommended halted a march to
peace. Interesting, there is not significant commentary on Ariel Sharon’s
actions in pulling Israel out of Gaza and his indications of taking unilateral
action in the West Bank when he had the stroke although Shin Bet information
was a significant factor in Sharon’s decision making regarding both
subjects. Both Rabin and Sharon understood the inherent problem with
ruling over a population that over time is going to be larger than the Jewish
population: regardless of all other issues this is a critical factor that this
movie directly addresses. Key to understanding the truth of the
film message is all six men have reached similar conclusions. As to
why my comment about foreign policy is that one of the themes presented is that
nothing bad comes from conversations with your enemies. At a minimum,
both sides learn that the other is not the devil or the anti-Christ. The
film also illustrates how basing foreign policy decisions on politics can lead
to serious long term negative consequences. Too much of what has occurred
is the result of tactics over strategy with Rubin and Sharon being the
exception. Seeing this film will provide an education no
matter how much you think you may know about Israel and Palestinian
politics. Further, the documentary holds your attention for the
entire 97 minutes. Unfortunately, I’ve heard Benjamin Netanyahu has not
seen this film. Final point: I cannot imagine any current Arab government
allowing a film such as Gatekeepers being made.
Sunday, March 31, 2013
Basketball: NCCA
I think this year is the first time I’m 0 for 4 on the final
four. I only had 2 teams out of the
final 8 this weekend. I had selected
Ohio State and Florida to make the elite 8 but I had both of them losing to
teams that didn’t make it out of the round of 16. I thought Miami would win it all but found
myself routing for Illinois and given the missed official call on an out of
bounds play with about a minute left, I wasn’t disappointed when Miami lost
their next game. I was surprised by how
many friends had picked Miami to win it all. But I
can’t believe only 2 out of 8 and a zero for the final round.
Syracuse defense has been superb. They usually are a good defensive club but
these last two games have been excellent.
I didn’t have either Syracuse or Marquette going past the round of 16. In other words, it is a good thing I wasn’t betting money on
my picks as I would have lost what I would have won in prior years.
I watched Louisville demolish Duke. I’m really disappointed that Louisville is living
up to its no. 1 ranking. I never route for a Rick P---- team. Does anyone know if Rick finally acknowledges
his stay in Hawaii on his resume? It
would be wonderful if Wichita State were to beat them on Saturday but that is
not a likely occasion.
With the very different defensive styles played by Syracuse
and Louisville, an April 8 championship game between the two of them could be fascinating
assuming Syracuse gets past Michigan.
There is something pleasurable about a number 1 team losing
even when it is only to a no. 2 team. Only
having one number one team surviving is a good thing. The 16 team division ranking system is part
of the pleasure of the NCCA tournament. As
usual, I’ve enjoyed watching some great basketball and looking forward to see
if another NC State Miracle can happen as to the Louisville game while
expecting the Michigan/Syracuse game to be close.
Monday, March 18, 2013
Movie: Oz the Great and Powerful
Oz the Great and Powerful: a children’s movie.
Beautiful colors and an interesting story line will not be enough for most
adults in this tale as to how Oscar Digs, aka Oz, got to the land of Oz.
If I had to use one word to describe the film, bland would be my choice. But
as I started to fidget in my seat, I noticed the young kids in the theatre were
really enjoying themselves. This may be the most Disney of Disney
films in years. There are scenes in the movie that reminded me of
the old Disney TV show: the fireworks
display is a good example. Anyone with a pre-teen child should take
the child to the film. You won’t dislike the movie and if you are
with your child, you may not find the 129 minutes quite as long as I
did. For adults, it wouldn’t have taken much to move the film into
the positive category. How about Johnny Depp as Oz? James Franco
was a dud as Oz. How about making the witches act like
witches? The children presumably liked it because these are the most
un-evil witches you may have ever seen and the good witch had no real
personality. We could also have done away with the scene where the
background song lyrics say freedom and we
suddenly see a black couple. I’m pleased Oz is integrated but… I know a lot of money was spent putting
this film together and you can sense it as you watch it. The film is
directed by Sam Raimi. When you see competent actors give blah
performances, you wonder about the director. In
this instance, however, I think it was faulty casting,
at least as to Franco. Mila Kunis, Rachel Weisz and Michelle Williams
play the three witches with Michelle also doing the opening character, Annie. Williams is not the only actor with
a dual role. The movie opens in Kansas (where else) in the year
1905. This opening sequence is in black and white. Oz has a
male assistant named Frank, played by Zack Braff, who is also the voice for
Finley the Monkey. Besides a monkey with wings, there is a talking
porcelain China doll instead of a lion and a man of straw. The acting
problems, except for Franco who was simply miscast,
was probably more the script than the director. It could be copyright
issues (Warner Brothers owns The Wizard of Oz) or the lack of female
input (credits overwhelming male). I saw the movie in 3-D. I think
if I’d seen it on a regular screen, it really would have been a long 2
hours. The photography was brilliant and the highlight for me in a
movie that clearly is not directed towards adults.
Saturday, March 16, 2013
Movie: Emperor
Emperor: a movie based upon actual
events. Tommy Lee Jones plays General Douglas MacArthur and the
place is Japan right after the WW II surrender. The question the movie
presents is whether Emperor Hirohito should be charged as a war criminal along
with Japan’s political and military elite who were responsible for the Pearl
Harbor bombing and subsequent events. Matthew Fox is General Bonner
Fellers, the individual MacArthur assigned to investigate whether the Emperor
should be charged. General Fellers is quite favorably portrayed and is
given a love interest. The favorable treatment I found quite
interesting as the real Gen. Fellers was a major figure in the John Birch
Society in the 1950/1960s. He also was unwittingly the person whose
messages to General Marshall while being assigned as Military Attaché to
the U S Embassy in Egypt in 1941 had been compromised by both the Germans and
the Italians leading to Alley losses: but I’m going off subject. The film
shows how devastated Japan was from the fire-bombing that occurred before Hiroshima. The film also
clearly sets forth the reality that a
significant part of the military command was not ready to surrender despite the
bombing destruction. Gen Fellers’ report accurately stated that it is
impossible to determine whether the Emperor could have stopped the war machine
and the decision to bomb Pearl Harbor but he clearly was the key person in the
surrender of Japan without a land invasion. I believe the first time
the Japanese public heard the voice of Emperor Hirohito was when he announced
over the radio that Japan surrenders. The fact that an attempt was
made to assassinate him before the address was played is portrayed in the
movie. The romantic parts of the
movie are the fiction although there is a factual base. Gen Fellers
did meet prior to the war a Japan female national attending college in
America. The sequences involving Aya (Eriko Hatsume) and her family
raise the film beyond being a well done piece for the History Channel. I enjoyed the scenes with Aya’s
military uncle. The Japanese characters are fully developed and not
portrayed as stereotype figures. Takataro Kataoka plays Emperor
Hirohito. The movie is directed by Peter Webber working off a
quality script by David Klass and Vera Blasi. The Japan occupation
is one of the few things General MacArthur did right in my opinion and I don’t
mind that Jones gives another excellent performance portraying him in a
favorable light. I enjoyed this 106 minute film and I was educated about
the historical background as to the wise decision not to have prosecuted the
Emperor.
Saturday, March 9, 2013
MOVIE: West of Memphis
West of Memphis: an excellent
documentary film about a failure in the criminal justice system. The
movie tells the story of three males who were teenagers when the incident took
place and who spent 18 years in prison. The title comes from the town
where the incident happened, West Memphis. The year was 1993 and
the incident was the murder of three young (8/9 yrs. old) boys whose bodies
were found bound and drowned in a drainage ditch and had the appearance of
having been mutilated. The prosecutor labeled the boys’ death a Satanic
Cult murder. One of the three accused had confessed. This
particular individual, however, was mildly retarded and the confession had
serious flaws. All three teenagers were into heavy metal. The
movie is not a reenactment and, as such, you are not visually exposed to the
violence; the descriptions, however, are enough. The sentences
handed down by the court were death for Damien Echols and life sentences for
Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley, Jr. All three men were released
in 2011. They had entered what is called an Alford guilty plea and got
time served. Translation: the accused were allowed to maintain
their innocence in the process of pleading guilty. Such a plea gives
the State immunity from a civil lawsuit. The individuals just wanted
their freedom. The movie clearly sets forth their innocence, including the
total lack of DNA evidence. What little DNA evidence did exist points to
the step-father of one of the deceased. Despite the serious issues
concerning evidence that existed from the beginning, it was only when the
Arkansas Supreme Court ruled in 2010 that the lower court had to consider DNA
evidence that the authorities began entertaining the release of the three
men. The movie also leaves you with the impression that if serious
“Hollywood money” had not been invested in proving their innocence, the three
men would still be in jail. The celebrities who became involved include
Johnny Depp, Eddie Vedder, Peter Jackson, the Dixie Chicks and Henry
Rollins. We are not told how much money was spent but it clearly exceed
$1 million by a significant factor. The 2 hour and 25 minute film was
directed by Amy Berg who was also the co-writer. It could have been
edited a little more tightly. The tragedy addressed in West
Memphis is not limited to the fact that the real killer was never jailed
and that people lost 18 years of their lives, but that the judicial system was
so reticent to admit that an error had been made. When you hear, for
example, the true story on the “mutilation”, you wonder how this all could have
occurred. If some of this story sounds familiar it’s because a
trilogy entitled Paradise Lost had been done while the three men were
still in jail. I’ve not watched the earlier films.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)